Developer's 2-acre Longboat Key site faces eminent domain takeover


The town’s planned new subaqueous wastewater pipeline will connect Longboat Key and Manatee County across Sarasota Bay. The pipe will be constructed parallel to the existing metal pipeline, which is now over 50 years old and leaked in 2020.
The town’s planned new subaqueous wastewater pipeline will connect Longboat Key and Manatee County across Sarasota Bay. The pipe will be constructed parallel to the existing metal pipeline, which is now over 50 years old and leaked in 2020.
Photo by S.T. Cardinal
  • Manatee-Sarasota
  • Share

The town of Longboat Key has begun the process of taking, through eminent domain, a 1.85-acre easement from a Bradenton private developer to make way for the town’s planned subaqueous wastewater pipeline.

At its Nov. 2 meeting, the Town Commission unanimously approved a resolution to authorize the town to work with attorneys “to acquire by negotiation, contract or legal proceedings, including eminent domain proceedings” an easement on land owned by Long Bar Pointe LLLP.

Bradenton-based Medallion Home, which is planning to develop the land adjacent to the parcel the town is seeking an easement on, is led by CEO Carlos Beruff. The Whitfield Avenue address for Long Bar Pointe in state records matches the address of Medallion Home in Manatee County. Beruff is a politically-connected and philanthropic leader in the Sarasota-Manatee region; he has served on the boards of Citizens Insurance, State College of Florida, the Sarasota-Manatee Airport Authority and the Southwest Florida Water Management District. The son of Cuban immigrants, he founded Medallion Home in 1984 and it has grown into one of the largest privately-held homebuilders in the region. 


Serious step 

Mayor Debra Williams, meanwhile, introduced the resolution as one that would authorize “easement acquisition through eminent domain” for the wastewater pipeline.

The town does not take the step lightly, Town Manager George Landry said, and Town Attorney Maggie Mooney said eminent domain has not been sought by the town since she started in her position in 2013.

“To put it on the spectrum of types of cases, eminent domain is kind of the most severe government action. It’s the power of taking private property for public use, and there’s protections in our Constitution for that,” Mooney said. “That’s why it’s highly regulated, and we don’t use it that often. I would say Longboat’s intention to explore and authorize the use of it is only being evaluated because it’s needed.”

The yellow outline on this map shows the shape and location of the easement Longboat Key hopes to acquire as it advances its wastewater pipeline replacement project.
The yellow outline on this map shows the shape and location of the easement Longboat Key hopes to acquire as it advances its wastewater pipeline replacement project.
Image courtesy of town of Longboat Key

Mooney emphasized that the town is not looking to take “the full bundle” of property rights from the landowner, but only an easement. The letter opener-shaped easement is adjacent to and surrounding an existing easement where the current wastewater pipeline sits.

The town and landowner in question have history that stems back to a 2020 leak that accentuated and made the need to replace the 51-year-old iron pipe urgent. The likely cause of the leak was corrosion from contact with a tree log or stump, according to a 2020 permit support document.

Millions of gallons of untreated sewage spilled into the mangrove fringe off Sarasota Bay over the course of 11 days, with estimates of the total amount spilled ranging from 11 million to 17 million gallons. According to a report by environmental consulting firm Environmental Science Associates, about 1.25 acres of wetlands were impacted by the sewer leak, and another 0.54 acres were damaged by an emergency dredge and fill project to construct a road to access the leak site and make repairs.

Landry said the owner, he later clarified he meant Beruff, believes the town owes him money because of damage to the land due to the spill and response. Reimbursement for the spill and the easement acquisition are two separate discussions, however, Landry and Mooney said.

Negotiations to purchase the easement from the property owner did not advance, which made eminent domain necessary, Landry said.

Beruff did not respond to requests for comment from the Longboat Observer, sister paper of the Business Observer. 


Five points

In Florida, eminent domain can only be pursued if there is a substantial public interest. State law expressly mentions sewer services or systems and pipeline facilities. The private party is also required to be justly compensated for the easement or purchase of the land. 

That is determined, if necessary, by a 12-person jury, a sign of how serious land ownership is taken in Florida, since the only other proceedings requiring a 12-person jury are capital cases, which can result in a death penalty sentence. 

The town of Longboat Key’s lift station on Gulf Bay Road pumps sewage into the subaqueous wastewater pipeline that traverses under Sarasota Bay and to a Manatee County treatment plant.
The town of Longboat Key’s lift station on Gulf Bay Road pumps sewage into the subaqueous wastewater pipeline that traverses under Sarasota Bay and to a Manatee County treatment plant.
Photo by S.T. Cardinal

The town has contracted with Gaylord Merlin Ludovici & Diaz, a law firm specializing in eminent domain cases. A memo written by firm partner Blake Gaylord states five factors must be considered by commissioners when determining the need for eminent domain action: safety, costs, alternatives, long-range planning and environmental factors. 

The memo details each of the five and accentuates the need for the timely replacement of the pipe, which is the only pipeline that transports sewage off the island for treatment.

“If the existing (pipeline) fails completely, the only fallback is trucking wastewater off the island,” Gaylord wrote. “That would take about 24 trucks running 24/7 to move the average daily flow of 1.6 mgd.”

A version of this article originally appeared on sister site YourObserver.com.

 

author

S.T. Cardinal

S.T. "Tommy" Cardinal is the Longboat Key news reporter. The Sarasota native earned a degree from the University of Central Florida in Orlando with a minor in environmental studies. In Central Florida, Cardinal worked for a monthly newspaper covering downtown Orlando and College Park. He then worked for a weekly newspaper in coastal South Carolina where he earned South Carolina Press Association awards for his local government news coverage and photography.

Latest News

Sponsored Content