Sarasota County declines to appeal Live Local ruling

D.R. Horton offers to drop 800-apartment plan in favor of previously denied 126-home proposal. But a county purchase is still, at least, possible.


The Smith farm property is on Raymond Road.
The Smith farm property is on Raymond Road.
Image via Google Maps
  • Manatee-Sarasota
  • Share

One thing is certain: Sarasota County will not appeal a circuit court judge’s ruling in favor of D.R. Horton in the Texas-based builder’s lawsuit over a development proposal for 50 acres adjacent to the environmentally sensitive Celery Fields.

But whether 126 single-family homes are developed there, or it’s 864 apartments up to 65 feet high or Sarasota County ends up owning the land will remain the topic of talks between the two in the coming weeks.

Boxed in by 12th Circuit Judge Hunter Carroll’s Nov. 4 ruling; a brief written by Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier in support of a literal interpretation of the 2023 law; a 30-day Dec. 4 notice-to-appeal deadline; and the potential cost of millions of dollars if the lawsuit – and others like it – were lost, county commissioners on Tuesday voted 3-2 to accept Carroll’s reasoning when he rejected Sarasota’s 70-page motion to dismiss Horton’s lawsuit.

“The Live Local Act’s explicit function is to authorize housing where local zoning dictates housing does not belong, provided the promise of affordable housing is met,” Carroll wrote. “The act’s displacement of the county’s zoning hierarchy is not a flaw in interpretation; it is the very design the legislature chose.”

Commissioner Tom Knight, essentially voicing the emotion and sentiment of his colleagues, including that of newly sworn-in Jim DeNiro, said there was no pleasure in coming to such a decision. He added that the passion of more than 50 people who came to speak about flooding and environmental effects of the proposed development was heard and understood, but perhaps better directed toward state legislators, given the intent of the Live Local Act.

The 50-acre Smith farm property is nestled in the southeast corner of the the Celery Fields, adjacent to a renowned bird sanctuary.
The 50-acre Smith farm property is nestled in the southeast corner of the Celery Fields, adjacent to a renowned bird sanctuary.
Image courtesy of the Sarasota Audubon Society

“It bothers me,’’ he said of Tuesday’s outcome. “I think it bothers all of us. We as a board did not create that law. We’re the ones trying to protect the community and do what’s right.’’

The vote is the latest wrinkle in a yearslong series of discussions, decisions and legal actions connected with the 50 acres, flanked on two sides by housing developments and two sides by the south cells of Celery Fields. Known as the Smith Farm, the acreage is zoned Open Use Rural (OUR), which allows one dwelling per 10 acres.

In 2025, commissioners denied D.R. Horton’s request to rezone the site to allow for a 170-unit and then a 126-unit residential development. Following the rejection, D.R. Horton turned to mediation.

This May, D.R. Horton requested a pre-application conference with Sarasota County to discuss a new proposal for the property — a plan calling for 864 apartments, the maximum allowed under the Live Local Act's provisions.

When Sarasota County said it would not process that application because the property was zoned OUR, the company sued in June.

A settlement offer presented to commissioners in October said D.R. Horton would resolve its litigation if allowed to build the 126-lot single-family subdivision. It was rejected.

Then, on Tuesday, an attorney for builder D.R. Horton told commissioners his client would back away from the apartment proposal altogether in return for an agreement on the 126-home plan. He was booed by the crowd.

In a letter to County Attorney Joshua Moye on Monday, attorney Charlie Bailey wrote: “This, of course, can only occur if the (Board of County Commissioners) is willing to enter a Settlement Agreement to this effect and subsequently approve the Rezone Petition to be memorialized in a duly adopted ordinance. If this occurs and the adopted ordinance becomes a final, unappealable development order (that is, no parties with standing timely challenge such development order), DHI would proceed to develop the single-family subdivision and withdraw its Live Local Application.’’

Speaker after speaker took the podium for about three hours, urging commissioners to appeal Carroll’s ruling and keep in mind the natural sensitivity of Celery Fields and the lands around it and the acreage’s ability to soak up excess rainfall.

Sarasota County resident Kelly Kirshner, a longtime activist and former Sarasota City Commissioner and Mayor who ran an unsuccessful campaign for U.S. Congress this year in District 16, which covers parts of Hillsborough and all of Manatee County, was one of many who spoke at the meeting. 

“There’s a lot of times when we have a nihilism and a fatalism in our politics that believes everything is eroding,’’ said Kirshner, a Democrat, who lost his Congressional campaign to Republican Sydney Gruters. “Celery Fields really represents the opposite of that, that we can take what was originally a massive wetland in the 19th century, … and we actually restored that and there’s an opportunity to continue to do that work and actually say no to the Mel Brooks-style film we’re watching to come in here and say that we can get 864 apartments but give us 126 houses instead on land that is zoned for five. It’s really silly.’’

Faced with what Moye called an “uphill battle,’’ commissioners not only voted to accept Carroll’s ruling but also voted 3-2 to immediately connect with D.R. Horton and its representatives over what comes next — the 126 homes, the 864 apartments or, as Commissioner Teresa Mast asked Bailey, if purchasing the site remains even an option. That option had been rejected by D.R. Horton previously.

“If it’s a conversation the county wants to have, we of course would return the county’s phone call,’’ Bailey said. “But our goal is to, D.R. Horton’s goal is to, either develop it as a single-family subdivision or, if it can’t develop in in that manner, Live Local is an option.’’

A version of this article originally appeared on sister site YourObserver.com.

 

author

Eric Garwood

Eric Garwood is the digital news editor of Your Observer. Since graduating from University of South Florida in 1984, he's been a reporter and editor at newspapers in Florida and North Carolina.

Latest News

Sponsored Content