Four Florida men convicted in $9M Pinellas VA cancer center scam

Prosecutors say an ineligible contractor received most of the money for a veterans treatment facility that was ultimately demolished.


A rendering of the now-demolished Cancer Infusion Therapy Center at the Bay Pines Veterans Affairs Medical Center.
A rendering of the now-demolished Cancer Infusion Therapy Center at the Bay Pines Veterans Affairs Medical Center.
Courtesy image
  • Tampa Bay-Lakeland
  • Share

A cancer treatment center being built at the Bay Pines Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Pinellas County was ultimately abandoned and demolished after taxpayers paid out $4.8 million under a fraudulent construction contract, federal prosecutors say. 

Now, four men have been convicted in the scheme and face decades in federal prison. 

A federal jury found Matthew West, 55, of Lantana, in Palm Beach County, and Kevin Kutina, 64, of Ramona, California, guilty of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and major fraud for their role in the multimillion-dollar construction contract, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Florida announced Tuesday.

The two men each face maximum penalties totaling 50 years in federal prison, prosecutors say. Sentencing hearings are scheduled for Feb. 4, 2027. 

Two co-conspirators have already pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud charges in connection with the ruse, prosecutors say. Robert Gonzalez, 61, of Palmetto Bay in Miami-Dade County and William Gonzalez, 54, of Orlando, both face up to 20 years in federal prison, the release says. 

The case centers on an $8.9 million contract to build a Cancer Infusion Therapy Center (CITC) at Bay Pines VA Medical Center in St. Petersburg’s Bay Pines area. 

Reserved exclusively for service-disabled veteran-owned small businesses, the VA contract instead became a vehicle to funnel most of the work and payments to an ineligible construction company, prosecutors say. 

The VA awarded the contract to build the 14,909 square-foot building to Maxon Groupe LLC Sept. 28, 2016, according to the September 2023 indictment. Prosecutors identified the company as owned and operated by the Gonzalez co-conspirators. Robert Gonzalez is a service-disabled veteran and therefore the company qualified under the terms of the VA’s bid for proposals. 

Behind Maxon Groupe winning bid, though, was an undisclosed arrangement with West Construction Inc., the Lantana-based contractor where Matthew West served as secretary and vice president, the indictment says. The defendants concealed that “Maxon was a pass-through for West, which managed nearly all of the work for the CITC contract and received most of the payment for the same,” the indictment says.

The arrangement between Maxon and West Construction circumvented a federal law established in 1999 to give service-disabled veterans more opportunities to win federal business contracts. The indictment describes the program’s eligibility requirements at the time as requiring the service-disabled veteran to own at least 51% of the business, hold the highest officer position in the business and have control over management and daily operations. 

West Construction Inc., a family-owned, full-service general contracting firm founded in 1969, does not meet that criteria for a service-disabled veteran-owned small business, or SDVOSB.

So, to meet technical experience requirements outlined in the request for proposals for the job, Maxon Groupe told the VA it was partnering with another SDVOSB, based in San Diego, called Kevcon Inc. that’s owned by Kutina, a retired Marine Corps Colonel and licensed contractor. In its proposal, Maxon Groupe told the VA it entered into a teaming agreement with Kevcon Inc. for the job and that qualified employees from Kevcon would serve in supervisory roles as Project Manager, Construction Quality Control Manager and Construction Project Superintendent. 

In reality, though, none of the three people listed in the proposal were real Kevcon employees, the indictment says. One individual was deceased. It was never disclosed to the VA that Maxon Groupe, Kevcon and West Construction shared employees, prosecutors say, nor was it disclosed that West Construction would be responsible for nearly all the work. 

A statement provided to a bonding company, also withheld from the VA, shows West Construction was set to receive most of the $8.92 million outlined in the agreement, the release says. And the companies continued to conceal West’s involvement even after they were awarded the contract. 

In an email quoted in both the indictment and the release, Kutina warned his co-conspirators to “never, NEVER, ‘NEVER’ expose the teaming agreement.”

“That is an internal document only relevant to WEST and his surety,” Kutina wrote in the email. “It isn't wise to expose it due to some of the language that is contrary to the SDVOSB program.”

Between March 2017 and January 2019, invoices submitted under the contract, which was riddled with false statements and omissions, led the U.S. Treasury to pay Maxon Groupe approximately $4.8 million, the release says. West Construction received about $4.2 million of those funds and paid Kevcon more than $350,000.

The 14,909-square-foot building the entities were hired to build was meant to be an expansion of the hospital’s existing radiation oncology clinic. In September 2016, the VA issued an announcement about the project, saying that, by 2018, the addition would add a new pharmacy and eight chemotherapy treatment stations to the facility, allowing more veterans to receive cancer care in one location. 

Instead, construction problems plagued the project and the partially-completed center was eventually demolished, prosecutors say, never to be rebuilt. 

The VA Office of Inspector General investigated the case, the release says. Assistant U.S. attorneys Tiffany E. Fields and Samantha J. Newman are prosecuting it. 

 

author

Anastasia Dawson

Anastasia Dawson is a Tampa Bay reporter at the Business Observer. Before joining Observer Media Group, the award-winning journalist worked at the Tampa Bay Times and the Tampa Tribune. She lives in Plant City with her shih tzu, Alfie.

Latest News

Sponsored Content