Private air service CEO seeks new trials in two fraud convictions

Patrick Britton-Harr wants a federal judge in Baltimore to rule prosecutors failed to present a case ‘beyond a reasonable doubt.’


  • Manatee-Sarasota
  • Share

Patrick Britton-Harr, the twice convicted felon who founded Sarasota’s private jet firm AeroVanti, has asked a federal judge to grant him a new trial or issue a judgement of acquittal for his conviction in an unconnected Medicare fraud scheme. 

The latest motion was filed Friday,  just days before a Tuesday afternoon ruling where the judge, overseeing both cases, scheduled a second evidentiary hearing on a request for a new trial in the AeroVanti case, where Britton-Harr was convicted on six counts of fraud.

Britton-Harr was convicted in October on five counts of health care fraud and one count of money laundering. Prosecutors claim — and a jury agreed — that he billed Medicare for $18.7 million worth of testing that was never performed during the pandemic.

His attorney, Gerald Ruter, writes in the motion that the government did not prove that Britton-Harr knowingly committed the fraud and that information related to COVID testing “passed through multiple hands, and an individual’s involvement in one stage did not necessarily establish knowledge of what occurred at another.”

“These circumstances do not excuse false claims, nor do they preclude proof of intent through circumstantial evidence,” he argues in the motion.

“They do, however, make it essential to distinguish errors or misconduct within the overall process from defendant’s knowing and willful participation in the charged fraudulent conduct.”

A proposed order included in the motion asks U.S. District Judge Adam B. Abelson to issue judgments of acquittal on the six counts or grant Britton-Harr a new trial.

(According to Harvard Law School, a judgment of acquittal can be issued if a “judge determines that the evidence presented by the prosecutor is insufficient to establish the defendant’s guilt as a matter of law.”)

Prosecutors have not filed a response to the motion, and it is not clear when, or if, there will be a hearing to discuss it.

Britton-Harr faces 60 years in federal prison in the Medicare case. He is scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 21.

But Patrick Britton-Harr’s Medicare fraud conviction is just one of two that could send him to prison for decades.

Earlier this year, he was convicted on six counts of wire fraud for bilking customers out of $14.7 million at his Sarasota and Annapolis, Maryland, private jet membership company AeroVanti.

He faces up to 120 years in federal prison for that case.

Ruter has also asked for a new trial in that case, alleging misconduct by a courtroom clerk. On Tuesday, Abelson ordered a hearing be held Dec. 14 and 15 to hear from witnesses, including jury members and the courtroom deputy.

Britton-Harr, once a rising entrepreneurial star in the region, has been convicted in both case of committing the fraud and using the proceeds to enrich himself.

In the case of AeroVanti, he sold $150,000 memberships meant for a service that allowed members to share the use of private planes. Instead, prosecutors said, he used the money to buy yachts and jewelry, pay for his living expenses and rent a $10,000 per month home near Tampa.

In the Medicare case, Britton-Harr, through his company Provista Health, offered COVID-19 tests to nursing homes, then billed Medicare $18.7 million for separate, high-priced respiratory pathogen panel tests that were supposedly conducted in a laboratory he owned in Arizona over the course of six months. However, the lab was closed, the tests were not conducted, and in some cases Britton-Harr billed Medicare for testing on nursing home residents who were already deceased.

Prosecutors say he used the money for himself, including buying a $112,500 Porsche 911, and making $25,000 monthly mortgage payments on an Annapolis waterfront mansion

In an interview with the Business Observer earlier this month, Ruter described Britton-Harr as “a genuinely a good man.”

“He’s an entrepreneur by nature,” Ruter said, “and sometimes entrepreneurs move too quickly and misstep.”

 

author

Louis Llovio

Louis Llovio is the deputy managing editor at the Business Observer. Before going to work at the Observer, the longtime business writer worked at the Richmond Times-Dispatch, Maryland Daily Record and for the Baltimore Sun Media Group. He lives in Tampa.

Latest News

Sponsored Content