- November 16, 2026
Loading
A popular Florida seafood restaurant has opened one location and closed another in the Sarasota-Manatee region.
Pinchers began serving customers on St. Armands Circle on Friday, Nov. 13, at its new location at 300 John Ringling Blvd. Its Lakewood Ranch location shuttered Monday, Nov. 9.
Specializing in seafood like crab and shrimp, Pinchers is one of more than a dozen concepts within the Phelan Family Brands portfolio. The family-owned restaurant business was established in 1997 with the debut of Pinchers Crab Shack in Bonita Springs and has expanded over the years to include other concepts like Deep Lagoon and Texas Tony’s Rib & Brewhouse.
The St. Armands Pinchers spans 8,000 square feet in a two-story space that for decades was home to restaurant-retail brand Tommy Bahama, which relocated to 465 John Ringling Blvd. following the 2024 hurricanes.
Days before opening on St. Armands Circle, Pinchers closed its Lakewood Ranch restaurant in a planned move, according to Phelan Family Brands CEO Grant Phelan. The Main Street eatery had been operating there since 2012.
“We were one of the first restaurants in Lakewood Ranch and had a good 14-year run,” Phelan says in a Nov. 16 phone interview. “The restaurant always did very well for us.”
Pinchers’ lease was up in Lakewood Ranch, Phelan explains, and upon looking around, he discovered the old Tommy Bahama location was available.
“So much competition had come into Lakewood Ranch,” he says, noting that when Pinchers first entered the market, the Mall at University Town Center had not even been built. “Now, that area has a lot of good restaurants, and we have our own competition with Deep Lagoon,” which has a restaurant in Waterside.
“The rent wasn’t all that different” between Lakewood Ranch and St. Armands, Phelan says, so the business decided to make the move.
The new location is larger — the Lakewood Ranch Pinchers had about 175 seats, while the St. Armands Pinchers has 250, Phelan says.
To staff the restaurant in St. Armands, Pinchers has 75 employees, according to Phelan. The majority of the Lakewood Ranch team is now working at the new restaurant, except for a couple of staffers who couldn’t make the drive and “found homes at Deep Lagoon Waterside,” he says. Pinchers had to hire about 20 additional people, he adds.
Currently, the Sarasota restaurant is in soft opening mode.
“We want to take it slow because it is a much bigger location for us,” Phelan says. “For now, we’ve only opened downstairs, but by Thanksgiving, we plan to have upstairs and downstairs” seating available for diners.
“It was a great opportunity for us, and we’ve always wanted to be in St. Armands Circle,” Phelan says. “It’s just such a beautiful area.”
There are 10 Pinchers locations along the Gulf Coast, from Marco Island to Wesley Chapel.