As neighbors keep fighting, Captiva’s South Seas plans grand reopening

Naples, Fort Myers and Charlotte

The new ownership of South Seas in Captiva, which is still in the midst of a fight with neighbors over some of its proposed changes, is hosting a grand reopening event Memorial Day weekend. The resort is using the four days later this month, which are tied to a fishing tournament, to unveil some of the changes its already made to the historic property — upgraded dining options, renovated pools, beach services, fitness amenities, The Clutch Golf Course and the Shops at South Seas. But even as it plans its initial victory lap, South Seas is still battling it out with locals who opposes the changes. Both parties testified before a Lee County hearing examiner earlier this year about a zoning proposal for the nearly $1 billion project and, according to an email last week from the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation, a decision should be announced in about 60 days. Along with the changes and updates its already made, South Sea’s ownership group wants to build 435 hotel rooms across two hotels on the property. The north hotel, which is replacing the former Harborside Hotel, will have 225 rooms. The south hotel will have 210 rooms and replace the former conference center. Plans also call for193 multifamily residential units. Those fighting the changes are opposed to increasing building heights and density which they fear will forever change the character and safety of Captiva.” But what SCCF has in fight, it lacks in confidence. In last week’s email, the group says that, “Judging from their demeanor at the hearings, the applicant and the county seem confident that the hearing examiner will recommend approval of the application.” The South Seas resort property is owned by WS SSIR Holdings, a joint ownership group which includes Timbers Co, Wheelock Street Capital and The Ronto Group. The partnership bought the 330-acre South Seas Island Resort (as it was then known) in 2021 for $50.38 million.